Why ‘Red, White, and Blue’ should bridge red vs. blue divide on Fourth of July

By Lee Edwards

As John Adams — that passionate advocate of “independency” — wrote, July Fourth should be commemorated with “Pomp and Parade, with [Shows], Games, Sports, Guns, Bells, Bonfires and Illuminations from one End of the Continent to the Other from this Time forward forever more.”

There’s a more serious side to July Fourth when we remember what makes America exceptional, as set forth in those truly revolutionary words in the Declaration of Independence:

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.  That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.

The Founders pledged their lives, fortunes, and sacred honor to protect the cause of liberty and the self-evident truth that all men, including kings, are created equal.

Public domain

Is it possible that this July Fourth, drawing on the wisdom of our presidents and the patriotism of the Declaration of Independence, we will set aside our differences and reaffirm our commitment to a red, white, and blue America?

Abraham Lincoln, who knew something about the unique character of America, praised the 56 men who produced the Declaration of Independence for their “coolness, forecast, and capacity to introduce into a merely revolutionary document an abstract truth, applicable to all men and all times” — that is, that “all men are created equal.”

No wonder, then, that in war, recession, and even a pandemic, our presidents have turned to the Declaration of Independence for inspiration.

On July 4, 1942, some seven months after Pearl Harbor, President Franklin D. Roosevelt said that never since it was first created in Philadelphia had July Fourth come “in times so dangerous to everything for which it stands.”

To the Army of the American Revolution, Roosevelt said, the Fourth of July was “a topic of hope and inspiration.”

“So is it now,” he added.

The men who were fighting for freedom, the president declared, took heart in its message—”the assurance of the right to liberty under God.”

On July 4, 2002, nearly 10 months after the terrorist attacks of 9/11, President George W. Bush, speaking in Jackson County, West Virginia, said that since the Declaration of Independence, “freedom has had a home, and freedom has had a defender.” Unlike any other country, the president said, America came into the world with a message for mankind—“that all are created equal and all are meant to be free.”

Bush quoted the Air Force pilot who, when asked if anyone on his base had a personal connection to the victims of September 11th, said, ”I think we all do. They were all Americans.”

As ever before, said Bush, America bore the hope of the world. From the day of our founding, the president added, “America’s own great hope has never been in ourselves alone. The Founders humbly sought the wisdom and the blessing of Divine Providence.”

On July 4, 2020, in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic, President Donald Trump held a “Salute to America” event at the White House. If you believe in freedom, he said, if you believe in peace, then “you must cherish the principles of our founding and the text of our Constitution.”

“It is a firm foundation upon which all progress is achieved,” he added.

The president praised the loyalty and the valor of the men and women of the military “who have defended our independence for 244 years.” He singled out the pilots and their aircraft whose “steel frames, broad wings, and roaring engines” symbolize America’s “soaring spirit and undying resolve.”

Never in history, he said, “has a nation used so much power to advance so much good.”

On July 4, 1986, President Ronald Reagan, speaking from New York Harbor, recalled that Thomas Jefferson and John Adams had bitterly parted after the contested election of 1800, but had reconciled with the passing of the years. That, said the president, “was their last gift to us, this lesson in brotherhood.”

America’s past, of which we are so proud, Reagan said, as well as our hopes, and aspirations for the future of the world and this much-loved country—“these things far outweigh what little divides us.”

We reaffirm, Jew and Gentile, we are one nation under God, the president said. Black and white, we are one nation indivisible. Republican and Democrat, we are all Americans.

“Tonight, whatever the trial and travail,” the president said, “let us pledge ourselves to each other and to the cause of human freedom — the cause that has given light to this land and hope to the world.”

Reagan urged that pledge of unity 35 years ago. Is such brotherhood possible today? Do we still believe in the motto, “E Pluribus Unum”? Are we stuck in a rigid mindset of red and blue, black and white, rich and poor? Or is it possible that this July Fourth, drawing on the wisdom of our presidents and the patriotism of the Declaration of Independence, we will set aside our differences and reaffirm our commitment to a red, white, and blue America?

The answer rests with us.

Lee Edwards is the distinguished fellow in conservative thought at The Heritage Foundation’s B. Kenneth Simon Center for Principles and Politics. A leading historian of American conservatism, Edwards has published 25 books, including “Just Right: A Life in Pursuit of Liberty.”

Image courtesy of Public domain

7 thoughts on “Why ‘Red, White, and Blue’ should bridge red vs. blue divide on Fourth of July

  1. My compliments to the author. It is sad to see comments in regards to this commentary from those who have chosen to throw in the towel in frustration and lament. This remains the greatest country on earth, despite those who whine about its demise. There is a true reason we have an immigration problem and countries like Iran, Cuba, China and Russia do not. And it’s not for free stuff; it’s because we continue to offer hope, promise and freedom. On this holiday I’ll celebrate that with anyone of any political stripe.

    • Joe, thanks for your thoughts on our great nation. It is still great.
      Unfortunately, there are those who do not think our nation is great. Those who peddle division, such as Critical Race Theory, or CRT, know exactly what they are doing. These are the kinds of threats to what could be a bright future for us, and we must remain vigilant. As a result of this kind of teaching and others, such as 1619 project, 64% of young adults are not proud of the USA. These topics have been pushed for years by some educators (not all) but we now see the results.
      I am not opposed to replacing CRT with a curriculum which will be uplifting to all students and instill a sense of pride in our nation. We need that very badly.

  2. Donald Trump is unworthy to speak about this nation’s veterans, when presented with the opportunity to serve his country he suddenly came up lame. He is unworthy of popping a pimple on a Veteran’s butt, mine included.

    • The following also receiveed deferments from 1964-1973. A few did eventually serve in the military, but they are in the minority. K A Jabbar, SJC Alito, John Ashcroft, M Ali, William Bennett, joe(potato head/ Biden, Roy Blunt, Michael Bloomberg, W Bush, Bubba Clinton, Dick Chenny, Pete Coors, Howard Dean, Mike DeWine, Bobby Fischer, Steve Forbes, Al Franken, Dick Gephardt, Newt Gingrich, Al Gore, Brit Hume, Davy Jones, Steven King, Trent Lott, Mitch McConnell, Joe Namath, Bill O’Reilly, George Pataki, Dan Quayle, Mitt Romney, Karl Rove, David Souter, Bruce Springsteen, Ken Starr, Steven Tyler, William Weld, Steve Wozniak. All of these citizens received some type of Military deferments as well. If you are going to call one citizen out…call them all out. Call them all unworthy. Michael J. Hall, KC-135A/Q Crew Chief P.A.F.B. N.Y.1976-1979. Thank you for your service Patrick.

      • Well, it seems like that would take a lot of time Michael J. Hall, they weren’t the topic at hand, and I don’t work for you. But other than that, sure! But why are you only listing those whose names we know? Absolutely let’s keep a database of those who chose not to serve their nation in wartime and shame them mercilessly. I’m all for it.

  3. Lee,

    This Countries’ motto of “E Pluribus Unum.” (Out of many cultures one culture.) This unique American cultural concept has been replaced by over 30 years of the Socialist/Communist brainwashing construct of Multiculturalism “E Pluribus Pluribus.” (Out of many cultures many cultures.). Diversity vs unity! Tribalism! No common belief system, no common values, no common goals. Divide and conquer by creating chaos aka, (“Multicultural Mayhem”)!

    This destructive concept went unquestioned by the majority of Americans as they happily drank the leftist’s Kool-aid. Now we have fallen victim to their plan of domination by requiring forced order thru total government control. So sorry, there is no American values remaining to jointly celebrate on the “Fourth of July”. “We are the World.” The third world of course.

Comments are closed.