Flemming: Attorney General gets tough questions on Global Warming Solutions Act

By David Flemming

On Jan. 23, Vermont Attorney General TJ Donovan testified before the House Energy and Technology Committee on the Global Warming Solutions Act (GWSA).

Rep. Heidi Scheuermann, R-Stowe, laid out a series of tough questions about what might happen if the GWSA passes:

Rep. Scheuermann: Could the Secretary (of the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources) propose an amendment that will be adopted to increase the gas tax by 20 cents a gallon in the state of Vermont? And then obviously the legislature doesn’t vote on it. Is that a problem?

Attorney General Donovan: Let’s research that and get back to you.

Rep. Scheuermann: If there is a problem legally, I’m worried about us (the legislature) ceding our authority on public policy matters such as these and delegating our authority and responsibility to the judiciary and the executive. How much authority are we giving them?

Attorney General Donovan: Let’s research that question on the revenue base and get back to you.

“Let’s research that and get back to you” isn’t the most reassuring phrase. Which is why Rep. Scheuermann’s question is a good one.

After all, a series of carbon tax proposals have been made in the past few years, funded by environmental groups from across Vermont. And yet, they have all been so unpopular that not one has come up for a vote in the Legislature. This bill could give the Agency of Natural Resources the authority to inflict a carbon tax on Vermont. Removing responsibility from our elected legislators is the surest way to make them unaccountable: “I didn’t vote for the carbon tax, ANR implemented it!”

Donovan made it clear that he was in favor of the legislation. Time and again throughout his testimony, Donovan made it clear that he supported the GWSA:

“We need to be ambitious on this. We are not setting up the government for failure.”

“Putting government’s feet to fire, in a way that prevents extreme liability.”

“It’s not going to bankrupt the state. We can’t be scared to act because we’re afraid of lawsuits.”

“This is a good bill. Know that we’ll be defending the government when the state gets sued. That’s how the system works.”

Rep. Scheuermann was most concerned about Vermont’s Legislature ceding constitutional legislative authority to the Agency of Natural Resources, part of the executive branch in Vermont’s government. However, Donovan’s comments reveal the disturbing extent to which Vermont’s executive branch in general has asserted itself in the process of making laws. Donovan himself serves in the executive branch under Gov. Phil Scott.

Donovan told the committee that “we (read: you legislators) can’t be scared to act,” by “putting government’s feet to fire,” emphasizing how the GWSA is a “good bill” which is “not going to bankrupt the state.”

According to the AG’s website, “the Attorney General is the chief law enforcement officer in the state.” Donovan’s job is to enforce the law, not cajoling legislators into acting to control a problem that is, at most, 0.1% “Vermont’s fault” (Vermont produces 0.1% of the world’s CO2 emissions).

And yes, he did say he would happily do the bare minimum for the job: “defending the government when the state gets sued,” such as what might happen if someone didn’t think Vermont was taking the GWSA seriously enough. What are the odds that Donovan would do his “very best” at defending Vermont versus doing a job that is merely “above suspicion”? Few without law degrees would know the difference.

Donovan may soon gain the ability to hold Vermont’s “feet to the fire” himself if the GWSA passes, biases and all. And that is a very bad thing for the impartial rule of law in Vermont.

David Flemming is a policy analyst for the Ethan Allen Institute. Reprinted with permission from the Ethan Allen Institute Blog.

Image courtesy of Vermont Secretary of State's Office
Spread the love

6 thoughts on “Flemming: Attorney General gets tough questions on Global Warming Solutions Act

  1. Listen, TJ will say whatever makes him look relevant on the big scene, as he has
    his eye on being part of the Big Political Field due to the fact of who we have in DC

    With Vermont’s three stooges in DC our senators, well one old babbling fool, another
    one thinks he’s going to be ” the leader ” in the free world, now here’s an Idiot and last
    but not least, VT’s lone congressman just there ……. following the parties agenda !!

    TJ, should fit right in !!

  2. 95% of CO2 sources are naturally created. Total human produced CO2 emissions only account for the 5%+- balance. That data is hard to find due to the insistence of the EPA and IPCC to cite human emissions data only and break percentages down by transportation, etc. Vermont’s forests are a net carbon sink for our own CO2 emissions. If you don’t take into account the entire picture of the CO2 cycle you’re missing the vast majority of what has always happened. The reductions called for in the Paris Accord are hardly background noise yet adhering to those goals would dramatically alter our lives. Forces beyond our control create climate change.

    • “Forces beyond our control create climate change.”

      And no amount of taxation by the fascist flatlanders will reverse
      those forces.. mother nature has a mind of her own unlike
      our feckless flatlander leaders who have no mind at all…at
      least not a functioning one..

  3. GWSA is a total waste of time. When will these folks start addressing the real issues such as under funded pensions, aging population, the exadous of out youth, the unfriendly business climate, high taxes just for openers. All through the fall leading up to the election, these issues are discussed at length. Once elected and arriving in Montpelier, the real important stuff is front and center – same sex marriage legalization of marijuana, et al. Sad, but true.

    • When will they address the real issues? They have by maintaining the status quo, declaring this is our government, not yours, and moving on to commit more public abuse and devising ever more creative ways to hide their trail from the peering public looking for answers as to why liberal policies are always dysfunctional. The press, that beacon of light which is supposed to illuminate FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PEOPLE just the kind of unaccountable governing we’ve seen in VT for years, is JUST AS MUCH A PART OF THE PROBLEM as ONE PARTY RULE is because they CHOOSE TO BE SILENT! SHAME ON THEM.

  4. Teejay yet again showing his leftist incompetence. Ready to sell off the farm to the fascist
    warming nazis neighbors without a clue of the consequences. Hooray for Rep Scheuemann
    to hold his feet to the fire, lets hope more do the same to all the warming fools who’d sell
    us out for the feelz good….

Comments are closed.