New police use-of-force report contrasts with narrative from the defund movement

At a joint hearing of the House Judiciary and Government Operations committees last Thursday, lawmakers heard Vermont’s public safety commissioner say current policing policies are sufficient to diffuse potential hostile situations between law enforcement officers and the public.

Michael Schirling, who heads up the Vermont Department of Public Safety, appeared before committee members and presented the findings of a new report on the Model Statewide Policy for Law Enforcement Use of Force.

During the meeting Schirling offered data that puts Vermont’s police activities in perspective, especially incidents involving use of force.

“The State Police respond to somewhere between 120,000 and 125,000 events per year; that conservatively creates about a quarter of a million contacts with the public,” Schirling said. “And on an annual basis the last three years there have been approximately 200 instances in which force beyond compliance and handcuffing was used.”

Public domain

USE OF FORCE: Lawmakers last year passed a law addressing use-of-force in the state. They are visiting the subject again, even as law enforcement leaders say force is sometimes a necessary action.

He said the number of incidents that require further examination is fewer still.

“Those things happen a handful of times any given year, but at the same time, there are literally thousands of events that are successfully de-escalated on a day-to-day basis,” Schirling said.

Last year lawmakers passed Act 165, which updates the state’s use-of-force policies. Schirling says the state’s law enforcement is already in the process of a “modernization strategy” that seeks to update protocols as appropriate.

“I just want to flag that that is something that has been in play throughout my career which spans back 30 years now,” he said. “De-escalation has been a key component of training and policy development in the operational landscape despite some of the narratives that have sort of driven our acceleration of these strategies in recent months.”

Police in Vermont are taught “alternative response models” that promote nonviolent outcomes. For 20 years mental health workers and social workers have been involved in police activity. According to Schirling, these non-law enforcement professionals work “in tandem with the criminal justice response.”

Also testifying before lawmakers was former Burlington Police Chief Jennifer Morrison. She said current legislation lacks language “that acknowledges the use of prohibitive restraint would be permissible when lethal force is justified.”

She said sometimes the use of force is the best way to prevent deadly force.

“[It works] for example if an officer is in a struggle where legal force is justified, and instead of using a firearm the officer uses a prohibitive restraint and the incident is resolved without serious bodily injury or death,” she said.

She said officers often don’t have much time to analyze a situation before critical decisions must be made, and she urged lawmakers to recognize that reality.

“There are instances where time and information do not allow this level of analysis,” she said.

Morrison said getting a variety of law enforcement groups to agree on one uniform policy was a challenge.

“It was a lot of work … getting everyone to a place where a statewide policy can be embraced,” she said.

In one exchange, Rep. Tanya Vyhovsky, P/D-Essex Town, told Schirling she believes police have not always had proper training in de-escalation tactics.

“What I’m saying is there are plenty of instances where we have seen people in like a mental health crisis die because people were not properly trained in use-of-force,” she said. “We have seen people have their heads bashed into the cement because people weren’t trained properly in de-escalation. So I’m not saying there is never a place, I’m simply saying there are plenty of places where actually de-escalation would work.”

Schirling responded by defending police training.

“The vast majority of the more than 125,000 instances that Vermont State Police respond to in any given year are de-escalated, and a tiny fraction of them result in the use-of-force,” he said. “An even smaller fraction result in an ugly use-of-force like the ones that you are describing.

“I cannot disagree strongly enough with the premise that there is a wide-spread fundamental problem here with the way in which Vermont law enforcement is trained and operates.”

Michael Bielawski is a reporter for True North. Send him news tips at bielawski82@yahoo.com and follow him on Twitter @TrueNorthMikeB.

Images courtesy of state of Vermont and Public domain

10 thoughts on “New police use-of-force report contrasts with narrative from the defund movement

  1. Standing O Mr. Bielawski – Mr Shirling at top of his game also – very grateful to have a pro heading up Dept of Public Safety 😀

  2. Newly proposed State of Vermont Welcoming Pamphlet

    WELCOME TO THE GRAVE LITTLE STATE OF VERMONT
    HISTORICAL FACTS
    ONCE RECOGNIZED AS THE PEDOPHILE CAPITOL OF THE U.S.A.
    SELF PROCLAIMED MOST DRUG ADDICTED STATE IN THE NORTHEAST.
    WIDELY RECOGNIZED FOR IT’S EMBEZZLEMENT EXPERTISE.

    SHOULD you REQUIRE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CONTACT OUR WHITE SUPREMACISTS STATE POLICE.
    PLEASE DON’T FORGET TO PAY A VISIT TO OUR STATE CAPITOL MOUNTPECULIAR.
    WE PROMISE A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE THAT WILL HAUNT YOU FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE!

  3. i guarantee who ever wrote this report never tryed to assert your fundamental right…fyi they are all gone .. you be on a list like your a slave from the 60’s in the south .. they will hunt you down and they will destroy you financially and the will kill you if you resit and you will goto jail.. they will frame you .. the entire system will cooperate. every reporter yout alk to will ignore you.. every office will ignore you…acab

  4. i guarantee who ever wrote this report never tryed to assert your fundamental right…fyi they all gone .. you list like your a slave from the 60’s in th south .. they hunt you down and they will destroy you financially and the will kill you if you resit and you will goto jail.. they frame you .. the entire system will cooperate. every reporter yout alk to will ignore you.. every office will ignore you…acab

  5. i dont care what those reports say ive dealt with these hostile state troopers they care not for your right and they care not what they do to you. they will mess you up. the entire legal system is rigged in vermont
    the barr the professional conduct board. the judges the lawyers.. its all rigged they even rigg the jurys.. the last state attorney resigned be being caught . thought things would get better but it gets worse.. the supreme court the lawyer say they dont work for you and you have no say .. they censor the comments in the videos. a blatant first amendment right violation.i called 30 lawyer and they they all say the same thing they dont do civil rights cases in vermont they are near imposable.. good luck with you crap report

  6. Best news article on the reality of Vermont policing in the last 5 years. VTDigger only reports the hand full of incidents, multiple times, over and over, so it looks like there is a major problem.

    Then half the time when they are doing their reporting with very few of the facts, which they ALWAYS paint a bad picture of the police…..when the facts do come out, low and behold, the officer couldn’t have been better. Remember all the articles about how we had anti-Semitic police? And when the video came out???? All of a sudden the story completely collapsed!

    VT Digger is complete propaganda and anti-law enforcement. They are not news. If they are looking for truth…they should just ask Michael, he can show them what a news article looks like, that gives an accurate picture of the our State Police.

    Well Done State Police, Well Done Michael, Well done True North Reports……

    • VTDigger is a left-wing propagandized paper. Just as the ol’ Bennington Banner is now too. REMEMBER: When you lose your Free Press, You lose your free country. But then again……with socialist Sanders still at the helm, that’s pretty much the goal, right?

      • that is the plan, they used it pretty effectively in this state, sadly. And the other side plays the perfect foil and here we are…..first colony of the New World Order

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *