Gun rights imperiled as state preemption laws face challenges

By Allan Evans

Firearm preemption laws across the country currently face legislative and judicial challenges as local governments seek to regulate guns, a trend which threatens Second Amendment rights, a National Rifle Association spokesman told the Daily Caller News Foundation.

“Preemption provides residents with a uniformed set of rules when it comes to owning, carrying, and using a firearm throughout the state,” NRA spokesman Lars Dalseide told the DCNF. Preemption laws remove the power of local governments to regulate firearm ownership, according to gun control advocacy group Giffords,which the group says prevents local officials from protecting their communities from gun violence.

Public domain

Gun rights organizations argue that preemption laws are essential in preventing localities from violating citizens’ Second Amendment rights, as well as eliminating confusion over the particular laws to which a citizen is subject as they travel throughout the state.

Colorado Gov. Jared Polis repealed the state’s preemption law Saturday, signing into law SB21-256 which allowed cities and counties to enact laws governing or prohibiting “the sale, purchase, transfer, or possession of a firearm, ammunition, or firearm component,” The law was proposed following a mass shooting in Boulder earlier this year that had prompted Democrats and activists to call for further gun restrictions.

“Colorado has been and will continue to be a national leader in firearm regulation,” a spokesperson for Polis told the DCNF ahead of a number of legislative and judicial challenges to preemption laws across the country.

Gun rights organizations, such as the National Rifle Association (NRA), argue that preemption laws are essential in preventing localities from violating citizens’ Second Amendment rights, as well as eliminating confusion over the particular laws to which a citizen is subject as they travel throughout the state.

“Dismantling that system creates a confusing patchwork of laws that place law-abiding residents in legal peril just for exercising their constitutional right to carry a firearm or to defend themselves and their families,” Dalseide said.

Gun control groups have focused on preemption laws in recent years, with the Coalition to Stop Gun Violence making the issue a central piece of their Safer States Initiative. Giffords has stated that one of its key policy goals is to “repeal preemption laws in states that already have them and resist their enactment in states that do not have them.”

With the passage of the new law, Colorado joins New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut and Hawaii as states without preemption laws, according to the Congressional Sportsmen’s Foundation. However, that number may soon grow as a number of legislative and judicial challenges to preemption laws are resolved.

Virginia, for example, enacted legislation gutting its preemption laws last year, allowing localities to pass laws regulating firearm possession in public buildings, parks and public roads when used for certain purposes. One such regulation is currently being contested in a lawsuit, LaFave v. County of Fairfax, filed by Virginia citizens along with the NRA.

Similarly, the Illinois state Supreme Court will hear a case later this year over a decision by Deerfield to ban civilian use of “assault weapons” and high capacity magazines, Capitol News reports. The plaintiffs, advocacy groups Guns Save Life Inc. and the Second Amendment Foundation, argued that the ban is preempted by Illinois state law, though an appellate court ruled in favor of Deerfield this March.

Oregon successfully amended its preemption laws earlier this month, enacting a law that permits certain local authorities to regulate firearms in public buildings. Lawmakers in Maine attempted to gut preemption laws this spring, with a bill allowing municipalities to create gun-free zones near polling places failing to pass.

Moreover, Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court took up a lawsuit challenging preemption laws in June, in which the city of Philadelphia sued for the right to enact its own gun laws. The city alleged that preemption laws infringe on residents’ rights to “life and liberty.”

Florida’s preemption laws withstood a challenge this April, with a state appellate court ruling against local governments in a reversal of the lower court’s decision. However, local governments filed notices last week asking the Florida State Supreme Court to take up the case, according to CBS Miami.

Gun rights advocates worry these local challenges will imperil gun owners and citizens alike. Dudley Brown, president of the Rocky Mountain Gun Owners, told The Wall Street Journal that repealing preemption laws will “open up the floodgates for woke city councils to disarm their citizens.”

“Repealing preemption laws is reckless, irresponsible, and will have no impact on reducing crime because the simple fact is that criminals don’t follow the law in the first place,” Dalseide told the DCNF.

As bills are voted on and lawsuits are decided, further gun restrictions may result as local governments assume more regulatory authority.

Content created by The Daily Caller News Foundation is available without charge to any eligible news publisher that can provide a large audience. For licensing opportunities for this original content, email

Image courtesy of Public domain

2 thoughts on “Gun rights imperiled as state preemption laws face challenges

  1. President Biden scoffed at the Second Amendment of The U.S. Constitution saying, American citizens who believe that the “Right to bear arms” to guard against a tyrannical government seizing power are fools if they think they would be successful in their struggle against his Government to regain their freedom! ” I got news for you man you ain’t going to do it with your AR15s, you would need jets and missiles to do that!” Well ok. I guess I’ll purchase mine from China, theirs are more advanced anyway plus they have some really great bio-weapons that they have recently tested out with tremendous success. They may be willing to sell them to me seeing how as an American Taxpayer I funded their development!

  2. Propaganda is strong.

    Please not the goal for many is to create division to keep their power and control, this is happening and being done on both sides of the aisle.

    I have not checked the below for accuracy, I do however, think it is closer to the truth than anything Vermont Digger has ever posted about the police. Now one has to ask this question, if the side for “law and order” know these facts……why aren’t that stating them? Why aren’t they from the roof tops screaming the truth?


    According to the FBI Uniform Crime Report and the Washington Post, last year there were 10 million arrests by police..10 Million!!

    Out of those 10 MILLION arrests, there were 1,004 officer-involved fatalities.

    Out of those 1,004 officer-involved fatalities, 41 were unarmed.

    Out of those 41-officer involved unarmed fatalities (now you might find it hard to believe I know), but out of 41 deaths, now hear this…

    19 were white – 9 were black.

    Now 1 is 1 too many, but to me, 41 out of 10 million is a pretty small percentage! (.00041%)

    Now ask me how many police officers were killed in the line of duty… c’mon, take a wild guess…

    89 police officers, but where was the news media when those took place????

    Just to bring it home, take a guess as to how many people were shot in CHICAGO just this last weekend. In Chicago last weekend 82 people were shot within a 48-hour period.

    Of those 82 people 19 died.

    Yes, you got it. In Chicago last weekend alone, there were more black people killed by (wait for it..) black people than were killed by police in all of last year!

    The hypocrisy is mind-blowing. Now go ahead, please do the research and see for yourself.

    Thank you to Bernard Kerik, former NYPD Police Commissioner for sharing this information.

    Pass this on. People have to know the ‘Fake News ‘/Democrats Agenda, which is: to divide America. The old Communist/Marxist tactic.

Comments are closed.